Skip to Main Content

Scholarly & Interdisciplinary Research

Questions to Ask When Evaluating Journals & Sources

If you find an article in the library's OneSearch, it should be from a reputable journal. However, if you are searching on Google Scholar or a similar platform, you might run across a source you aren't familiar with you might be uncertain whether or not it is a legitimate source to cite to. You can always ask a librarian for assistance, but you can also ask the following questions to evaluate your source:
Check the publisher (Academic press? Commercial publisher?)
Check the editorial board
Does the journal publish in a sufficiently narrow area? (e.g. not The Experiment Journal)
Does the journal publish outside its area of expertise? (e.g. is a science journal publishing political articles)
Is the article peer-reviewed?
Check the Directory of Open Access Journals if the journal is open access. The DOAJ tries to only include reputable open access journals, instead of predatory journals.
Is it cited by reputable scholars?
Check journal rankings and citation studies